Adobe CDP and Treasure Data both are platforms that allow you to sync data to downstream marketing destinations like CRM tools, email tools, and advertising platforms. Both platforms have the functionality to collect events via an SDK, and functionality to resolve identities.
However, there are plenty of differences across feature sets, functionality, usability, and more. Below we take a deep-dive into both platforms to highlight the differences.
Compare Adobe CDP and Treasure Data
| Functionality | Adobe CDP | Treasure Data |
|---|---|---|
| Data Collection | Client-side, server-side, & other 3rd-party sources | Client-side, server-side, & other 3rd-party sources |
| Data Storage | Adobe's managed infrastructure | Treasure Data's managed infrastructure |
| Data Retention | Variable | Variable |
| Data Schema | Controlled by Adobe (supports users, accounts, & events) | More flexible than most traditional CDPs, more difficult to set up than Composable CDPs |
| Audience Management | No-code audience builder (integrates with some data warehouses, but limited 250 syncs per destination) | Limited audience-building capabilities for non-technical users |
| Journey Orchestration | Yes (add-on product) | Yes |
| Identity Resolution | Deterministic IDR managed in Adobe's infrastructure | Deterministic IDR managed in Treasure Data's infrastructure |
| Identity Graph Storage Location | Owned by Adobe | Owned by Treasure Data |
| Reverse ETL | NA | NA |
| Real-Time Audience Computation | Yes (limited to clickstream/behavioral data with no time-based lookbacks) | Yes (limited to clickstream/behavioral data with no time-based lookbacks) |
| Real-Time Streaming (Event Forwarding) | Yes | Yes |
| Low-Latency Profile API | Yes | Yes |
| Streaming Reverse ETL | No | No |
| Data Activation Flow | Adobe CDP to destination | Treasure Data to destination |
| Activation Destinations | Adobe ecosystem (limited support for external destinations) | 170+ |
| Source of Truth | Multiple: Adobe & your owned data warehouse | Multiple: Treasure Data & your owned data warehouse |
| Security & Compliance | Data lives outside of your cloud infrastructure (can be configured to be GDPR, CCPA, & HIPAA compliant) | Data lives outside of your cloud infrastructure (can be configured to be GDPR, CCPA, & HIPAA compliant) |
| Pricing | Bundled pricing: dependent on monthly tracked users (MTUs) & feature add-ons | Bundled pricing: dependent on monthly tracked users (MTUs) & feature add-ons |
| Proof of Concept (POC) | 4-6+ months | 4-6+ months |
Pros and Cons of Adobe CDP
Pros
- Strong integrations with the Adobe ecosystem (Adobe Target, Adobe Analytics, Marketo, etc.)
- Segmentation builder has some basic AI capabilities
- Identity resolution supports clean room use cases through a “Co-op graph” for Adobe CDP customers
Cons
- Very expensive (lots of add-on products required)
- Limited integration support for external tools & systems
- Event collection is only accessible through Adobe's closed-source library
- Long implementation time & difficult setup process
- Inflexible data data model/schema (cannot support custom objects & entities)
Pros and Cons of Treasure Data
Pros
- Data engineering & analytics functionality
- AI/ML capabilities
- Strong support for Japanese-specific brands/companies
Cons
- Not marketer-friendly (built for data teams)
- Architecture is built on legacy technology (Presto & Hive)
- Requires substantial data engineering resources to implement & maintain
- Identity graph is owned Treasure Data
Should I Buy Adobe CDP or Treasure Data?
Before you purchase a customer data platform, there are a few important factors to consider:
-
Time-to-value: You need to show ROI quickly to your internal stakeholders to validate that the platform can provide business value. Many customer data platforms can take upwards of 6-12 months to implement and get started.
-
Usability: Tools like Segment and ActionIQ can come with steep learning curves that make them difficult to use, especially for non-technical marketing teams. It doesn't matter how good the technology is if your marketing team doesn't use it.
-
Functionality: Before you purchase any tool you need to ensure that it has functionality to solve your business-specific use cases, and that means supporting your proprietary data. Your main goal should be to purchase a solution that actually solves the problem you're facing.
-
Flexibility: Not every company is the same. Make sure the tool you're purchasing can dynamically adapt and conform to your data. Otherwise, you'll end with a failed implementation and an upset marketing team.
What's the Best Alternative to Adobe CDP and Treasure Data?
Hightouch is a Composable Customer Data Platform that is the perfect alternative to both Segment and ActionIQ because the platform offers the following:
Fast Implementation: Hightouch enables you to start activating your data immediately. The average customer is powering live use cases within weeks and sometimes days.
Ease-of-Use: Hightouch was specifically built for non-technical users. The platform has an easy-to-use audience builder, built-in analytics, and experimentation and measurement capabilities your marketers can drive value and optimize performance without getting blocked by your data team.
Completeness: Hightouch offers a complete suite of capabilities to collect data, resolve identities, build audiences, sync data to any destination, and increase match rates. You won't end up with a bloated tech stack because you can select the functionalities you need for your specific use cases.
Flexibility: The Composable CDP approach that Hightouch provides allows you to have the most flexible data activation solution. Unlike traditional CDPs, Hightouch lets you access any data in your organization and use any schema structure imaginable to power your most complicated marketing use cases.
Our team of experts at Hightouch is comprised of former CDP experts, so if you have any questions about CDPs, schedule some time with a Hightouch expert so we can point you in the right direction.
